Los Angeles Times: "Iraq Got U.S. Technology After CIA Warned Baker"

Home
ABC News: "DOJ Official Fired in Wake of ABC News Investigation"
Los Angles Times: "Bleak House"
Los Angeles Times: "Despite Ban, U.S. Arms are Sold to Pakistan"
Los Angeles Times: "U.S. Knew Pakistan Arms Sales Broke Law, Pell Charges"
Los Angeles Times: "Iraq Got U.S. Technology After CIA Warned Baker"
Los Angeles Times: "U.S. Paying Off Bad Iraqi Debt"
Los Angeles Times: "Bush Had Long History in Support of Iraq Aid"
Boston Globe: "Lawyers Battle Over Iran-contra Final Report"
National Journal: "Secret Service Records Prompted Judith Miller to Change Testimony"
National Journal: "Internal Affairs"
National Journal: "Secret Order by Gonzales Granted Extraordinary Power to Aides"
Naitonal Journal: "What Bush Was Told About Iraq"
Naitonal Journal "Key Intelligence Briefing Kept from Congress"
National Journal "Insulating Bush"
National Journal: "Cheney Authorized Libby to Leak Classified Information"
National Journal: "Justice Aide Says He Was Directed to Call Proseucutors"
Washington Post: "A Favor for a Felon"
Los Angeles Times: "High-Tech Aid Flowed As Iraq Built Up Forces"
Los Angeles Times: "U.S. Bent Aid Rules to Gain Turkey's Help In Gulf War"
Washington Post: "Noriega: A Probe That Fizzled"
Los Angeles Times: "Special Counsel Sought on Aid to Iraq"
L.A.Times: "U.S. to OK High-Tech Sales to Iran and Syria"
Boston Globe: "Reagan Tapes Iran-contra Testimony"
"National Journal: "Administration Withheld Emails About Rove"
National Journal: "Cheney's Call"
Los Angeles Times : "Italian Report Suggests U.S. Knew of Bank's Loans for Iraqi Military"
Salon.com: "Clinton administration failed to monitor China's use of missile-technology exports"
Los Angeles Times: "Kuwait, Saudis Supplied Iraq with U.S. Arms"
Los Angeles Times: "Saudi Arms Link To Iraq Allowed"
ABC News "Bush White House Pushed Grant for Former Aid"
ABC News: "White House Involved in U.S. Attorney Firings"
The Hill: "Bush Administration Leaks Bolstered Renzi Reelecton Bid"
Los Angeles Times: "U.S. Loans Indirectly Financed Iraq Military"
Los Angeles Times: "Abuses in U.S. Aid to Iraq Ignored"
Los Angeles Times: "Bush Secret Effort Helped Iraq Build Its War Machine"
Washington Examiner: "The Baron's Last Exit"
Arkansas Times
The American Prospect "The Meeting"
Murray Waas articles on Talking Points Memo
Los Angels Times: : "U.S. Gave Intelligence Data to Iraq Three Months Before Invasion"
Los Angeles Times: "Bush Tied to `86 Bid To Give Iraq Milirary Advice"
Los Angles Times: "Jordan Gave Iraq Broad Military Assistance"
Village Voice: "While You Were Watching Katrina"
New Republic: "Media Specter"
Los Angeles Times: "Iraq Used American-Built Plant to Develop A-Arms"
Los Angeles Times: "Iraq's $5 Billion Windfall Spins Deepening Mystery"
Most recent stories
Murray Waas articles in Time Magazine
Murray Waas articles in the New Yorker
Murray Waas articles in the Nation
Huffington Post: "Former U.S. Attorney Condemns Bush"
Murray Waas articles in the American Prospect
Murray Waas articles in Village Voice
Murray Waas: Articles in the Atlantic
Los Angeles Times: "U.S. to OK High-Tech Sales to Iran and Syria"
Village Voice: "Jack Anderson: An Appreication"
Murray Waas: Articles in the Atlantic
Murray Waas articles in The New Republic
Murray Waas stories on Mike Huckabee
Articles on Justice Department grants programs
Exclusive: Cheney's Interiview with the Special Proseucotr
The United States v. I. Lewis Libby
Articles on prewar intelligence and the Fitzgerald Investigaton
Journalism Criticism by and About Murray Waas
Articles about U.S. Attorney Firings and Alberto Gonzales
Murray Waas articles in New York Magazine
Murray Waas biography

Los Angeles Times
July 22, 1992, Wednesday, Home Edition
IRAQ GOT U.S. TECHNOLOGY AFTER CIA WARNED BAKER;
WEAPONS: DESPITE THE NOTICE ABOUT BAGHDAD'S NUCLEAR EFFORTS, SECRETARY SAID EXPORTS WOULD NOT BE CURTAILED.


BYLINE: By MURRAY WAAS and DOUGLAS FRANTZ, SPECIAL TO THE TIMES; Waas is a special correspondent and Frantz is a Times staff writer.

SECTION: Part A; Page 1; Column 1; National Desk

LENGTH: 1623 words

DATELINE: WASHINGTON

The CIA warned Secretary of State James A. Baker III in a September, 1989, top-secret assessment that Iraq was developing a "nuclear weapons capability," and the agency identified the specific technology being sought by Baghdad, according to classified documents.

Nevertheless, a month later, Baker assured Iraq's foreign minister that the Bush Administration had no plans to tighten controls on technology exports to Iraq.

That November, Baker played a decisive role in approving an additional $1 billion in U.S. food aid for Baghdad -- despite another warning that federal prosecutors were investigating allegations that Iraq may have used earlier aid to acquire nuclear-weapons technology.

The CIA analysis was one of numerous intelligence reports to Baker and other senior Bush Administration officials detailing the activities of Iraq's clandestine worldwide arms-procurement network, according to records obtained by The Times.

The newly disclosed documents demonstrate that the intelligence reports were transmitted to the highest levels of the Administration. Yet officials declined to impose restrictions or take other measures that might have slowed Iraq's efforts to develop a nuclear weapon.

The new documents also provide additional evidence of the extent of the Administration's knowledge of Iraq's arms procurement efforts in the years before the invasion of Kuwait.

State Department spokeswoman Margaret Tutwiler, traveling with Baker in the Middle East, declined to respond to questions about the CIA analysis.

"We are going to follow the same policy on this story as we have on the past ones, which is not to get into all the specifics or try to interpret documents that were made available," Tutwiler said. "Secretary Baker and others have talked about prewar policy. We've testified on it; we've released documents publicly, and we've released them (documents) to the Congress."

Classified documents previously disclosed by The Times already have shown that the Administration was warned repeatedly, starting as early as 1985, by its own intelligence agencies that Iraq was developing nuclear, chemical and biological weapons, possibly with diverted U.S. technology.

Post-Persian Gulf War inspections by the United Nations have demonstrated that U.S. technology was used in Iraq's weapons programs. Allegations that U.S. food aid was diverted to buy weapons are still under federal investigation.

Paradoxically, at the start of the Gulf War, President Bush invoked Iraq's potential to develop and deploy nuclear weapons as one reason for launching the air war instead of continuing economic sanctions.

"We are determined to knock out Saddam Hussein's nuclear bomb potential," Bush told the nation in a televised address on Jan. 16, 1991.

Confronted with questions about prewar assistance to Iraq in recent weeks, the President has denied repeatedly and categorically that his Administration provided any help in Baghdad's drive to develop nuclear, chemical or biological weapons.

Classified records have shown that the Administration resisted efforts to curtail sales of sensitive technology to Iraq as late as May, 1990, two months before the invasion.

In the CIA assessment dated Sept. 3, 1989, Baker and other officials were informed that Iraq was developing a nuclear weapon to "counter perceived military threats from Israel and Iran." Iraq's front companies had "made extensive use of covert techniques in Western Europe" to obtain high-tech goods vital to its nuclear weapons program, the report said.

Technology identified by the CIA included high-speed cameras, oscilloscopes and sophisticated computers. Records show that the Administration allowed such technology to go to Iraq even after the warnings, continuing a policy begun as part of the Ronald Reagan Administration's attempt to influence Iraqi President Hussein.

On Oct. 6, 1989, Baker met with Iraqi Foreign Minister Tarik Aziz in Washington. Minutes of the meeting show that Baker stressed the Administration's desire for strong ties to Baghdad and said it opposed attempts by Congress to impose sanctions on Iraq.

"Regarding technology, the secretary admitted that the U.S. does have concerns about proliferation but they are worldwide concerns," the minutes said. "He suggested that we work together on specific requests so the U.S. can understand Iraqi needs and objectives and Iraq can hear what concerns us."

At the meeting, Aziz raised concerns about alleged efforts by the United States to destabilize the Iraqi government. On Oct. 21, 1989, Baker sent a classified cable to Aziz in which he said that he has discussed the matter with Bush and that there was no such U.S. effort.

"Such an action would be completely contrary to the President's policy, which is to work to strengthen the relationship between the United States and Iraq whenever possible," according to a copy of the cable.

An examination of records of the interagency Administration group that reviews exports of technology with potential nuclear weapons uses found that substantial amounts of such goods were licensed for sale to Iraq.

Between 1985 and 1990, the Reagan and Bush administrations approved 410 licenses to Iraq for goods with potential nuclear applications, while disapproving 116, records show.

Congressional and federal investigators now say they have uncovered evidence that one element of Iraq's procurement network, a Cleveland machine-tool company called Matrix Churchill, obtained tens of millions of dollars in U.S. technology for Iraq's nuclear program.

Matrix Churchill was not shut down by the Customs Service until the month after Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, despite intelligence reports dating back to the summer of 1989 that identified its British parent, also known as Matrix Churchill, as part of the worldwide procurement network.

Intelligence warnings also came as the Administration was considering new loan guarantees for Iraq.

"Baghdad has created a complex procurement network of holding companies in Western Europe to acquire technology for its chemical, biological, nuclear and ballistic missile program," said a Nov. 6, 1989, secret CIA report naming Matrix Churchill and numerous other fronts.

Two days later, the Administration approved the additional $1 billion in loan guarantees for Iraq from the Commodity Credit Corp. over objections of four federal agencies worried about Iraq's credit-worthiness and the allegations of aid diversion.

The approval followed personal lobbying by Baker and top aides. Records show that, along with the September CIA report, Baker also had received another classified report about that time that raised suspicions about possible diversion of U.S. aid.

The report said federal prosecutors were investigating "allegations of widespread and blatant 'irregularities' in the CCC program for Iraq." Among the allegations was possible "diversion and transshipment of commodities outside Iraq" for arms purchases.

Three of Baker's top aides were warned that investigators believed "that diverted funds were used to procure nuclear related equipment" and that Matrix Churchill was "involved in supplying military hardware to Iraq."

The warnings continued. Two weeks later, a State Department memo said intelligence information indicated that Iraq was pursuing "a nuclear explosive capability" with the assistance of Iraq's clandestine network.

Although the memo warned that some U.S. high technology was diverted for Iraq's nuclear program, it argued that Administration policy was to "improve relations with Iraq, including trade, which means . . . exports of dual-use commodities for conventional military use may be approved." The memo also charged that licensing policy was holding back exports to Iraq.

In mid-February of 1990, U.S. diplomats in nine foreign capitals were instructed to express concerns about Iran's and Iraq's nuclear programs. The diplomats were to urge the "host governments not to provide either Iran or Iraq with 'plutonium or highly enriched uranium' " to make a bomb and, more important, were "cautioned against the export of so-called 'dual-use' items to the nuclear programs of Iran or Iraq."

But contrary to the advice given U.S. allies, senior Bush Administration officials continued to press for relaxation of U.S. export licenses that might assist Iraq's nuclear program.

In March, 1990, John Kelly, then an assistant secretary of state who also had received the September, 1989, CIA warning, complained that the interagency licensing policy was still holding up export licenses to Iraq. "We have explicit presidential authority for expanding trade with Iraq," Kelly said.

On March 27, 1990, U.S. and British customs agents thwarted an effort by Iraq to obtain American-made triggers for nuclear weapons.

Within days, a State Department official warned in a classified memo that the incident was "another indication that Iraq may be seeking to develop a nuclear weapons option. Although this does not appear to be a danger in the near term because Iraq lacks facilities to produce weapons-grade nuclear materials . . . it is important to try and prevent Iraq from acquiring sensitive technologies at an early stage."

A senior State Department official was being dispatched to France, West Germany, Belgium and other countries to brief foreign leaders on "Iraq's nuclear program and procurement activities" and argue for "the need to control exports of sensitive nuclear and missile technology to Iraq," according to the memo.

But in May and June of 1990, according to classified documents, the National Security Council rejected proposals by the Commerce Department to tighten the export licensing of U.S. technology to Iraq.

Waas is a special corrrespondent and Frantz is a Times staff writer.  

PERSON:  GEORGE W BUSH (51%); SADDAM HUSSEIN  (51%); SADDAM HUSSEIN (51%); 

ORGANIZATION:  CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY  (92%); CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY (92%); 

COUNTRY:  UNITED STATES (95%); IRAQ (94%); KUWAIT (79%); MIDDLE EAST (79%); GULF STATES (73%); 

CITY:  BAGHDAD, IRAQ (93%); 

COMPANY:  CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY  (92%); CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY (92%); 

GEOGRAPHIC:  UNITED STATES (95%); IRAQ (94%); KUWAIT (79%); MIDDLE EAST (79%); GULF STATES (73%);   BAGHDAD, IRAQ (93%); 

SUBJECT: TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER; BAKER, JAMERS A III; CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY; NUCLEAR WEAPONS -- IRAQ; WEAPONS RESEARCH; UNITED STATES -- FOREIGN AID -- IRAQ; UNITED STATES -- FOREIGN POLICY -- IRAQ; BUSH, GEORGE; GOVERNMENT DOCUMENTS; MATRIX CHURCHILL (COMPANY)  NUCLEAR WEAPONS (93%); MILITARY WEAPONS (93%); US FEDERAL GOVERNMENT (91%); EXPORT TRADE (90%); INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS (90%); INVESTIGATIONS (90%); INTELLIGENCE SERVICES (90%); INTERNATIONAL ASSISTANCE (90%); ARCHIVE COLLECTIONS (89%); STATE DEPARTMENTS & FOREIGN SERVICES (89%); DESERT STORM (89%); FOREIGN POLICY (78%); CHEMICAL & BIOLOGICAL WEAPONS (78%); FOREIGN RELATIONS (78%); EMBARGOES & SANCTIONS (76%); JUSTICE DEPARTMENTS (75%); TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER (72%); UNITED NATIONS INSTITUTIONS (65%); US PRESIDENTS (60%); 

LANGUAGE: ENGLISH

TYPE: Main Story
Copyright 1992 The Times Mirror Company; Los Angeles Times

 All Rights Reserved